Active Listings
49
⇩ 12.5% vs 56 last year
Population: 3,129 · Density: 128.8/mi² · Median household income: $98,409
Typical home value: $934,498 · Homeownership: 88.5%
Data as of January 2026. Source: Realtor.com.
The SHELTER ISLAND, NY real estate market (11964) currently shows 49 active listings, with 4 pending sales. Homes are averaging 184 days on the market before going under contract.
Inventory has tightened compared to last year, with 7 fewer active listings — creating more competition among buyers.
Homes are taking longer to sell, averaging 184 days on market compared to 157 days last year.
The median listing price has fallen 14.4% year-over-year, from $2,745,000 to $2,349,000.
Whether you are buying or selling in SHELTER ISLAND, NY, SELL123.com can help you save significantly on commission — typically 2% compared to traditional 5% broker fees. Call (240) SELL-123 for a free consultation.
| Zip | City / State | Distance | Listings | Market Value | Median $ | Average $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11964 | Shelter Island, NY 11964 | 0.0 mi | 49 | $177,029,356 | $2,349,000 | $3,612,844 |
| 11963 | Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | 4.0 mi | 129 | $579,053,781 | $3,250,000 | $4,488,789 |
| 11939 | East Marion, NY 11939 | 5.0 mi | 8 | $12,750,856 | $1,572,500 | $1,593,857 |
| 11957 | Orient, NY 11957 | 6.9 mi | 16 | $65,482,864 | $2,699,000 | $4,092,679 |
| 11958 | Peconic, NY 11958 | 7.8 mi | 0 | $0 | $1,695,000 | $1,695,000 |
| 11962 | Sagaponack, NY 11962 | 8.6 mi | 14 | $377,545,000 | $17,247,500 | $26,967,500 |
| 11976 | Water Mill, NY 11976 | 9.0 mi | 79 | $881,342,091 | $6,995,000 | $11,156,229 |
| 11956 | New Suffolk, NY 11956 | 9.6 mi | 2 | $3,600,000 | $1,800,000 | $1,800,000 |
| 11968 | Southampton, NY 11968 | 12.2 mi | 191 | $1,318,698,571 | $3,750,000 | $6,904,181 |
| 11948 | Laurel, NY 11948 | 14.2 mi | 9 | $13,516,497 | $882,000 | $1,501,833 |
| 11947 | Jamesport, NY 11947 | 16.0 mi | 8 | $20,282,664 | $1,695,000 | $2,535,333 |
| 06475 | Old Saybrook, CT 06475 | 17.3 mi | 30 | $38,111,250 | $944,900 | $1,270,375 |
| 11954 | Montauk, NY 11954 | 18.9 mi | 81 | $302,851,305 | $2,575,000 | $3,738,905 |
As of January 2026, there are 49 active listings in SHELTER ISLAND, NY (zip code 11964), compared to 56 the prior year.
The median listing price in SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 is $2,349,000 as of January 2026, a 14.4% decrease from $2,745,000 the prior year.
Homes in SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 spend an average of 184 days on the market before going under contract, compared to 157 days the prior year.
Based on current inventory and days-on-market data as of January 2026, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 is currently a Balanced Market. Inventory has tightened compared to last year, with 7 fewer active listings — creating more competition among buyers. Homes are taking longer to sell, averaging 184 days on market compared to 157 days last year.
With SELL123.com's maximum 3% commission, sellers in SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 save an estimated $46,980 compared to a typical 5% commission on the median listing price of $2,349,000. Our fee structure: 1% listing + 2% selling broker — no additional buyer or seller fees. Call (240) SELL-123 or email info@SELL123.com for a free consultation.