Call or Text (240) SELL-123
Kelleys Island (Kellys Island)

KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438

Real Estate Market Report  ·  Erie County
Balanced Market
October 2026  ·  Source: Realtor.com

Neighborhoods in ZIP 43438

Kelleys Island (Kellys Island)

Market Analysis

Data as of October 2026. Source: Realtor.com.

The KELLEYS ISLAND, OH real estate market (43438) currently shows 10 active listings, with 2 pending sales. Homes are averaging 37 days on the market before going under contract.

Inventory has increased compared to last year, with 6 more homes available — giving buyers more choice.

Homes are selling faster, averaging 37 days on market compared to 73 days last year.

The median listing price has risen 37% year-over-year, from $437,900 to $599,900.

★ Page Sponsor
🏠
Sponsor This Market
Realtors & Brokers — reserve this page for KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438 and connect with motivated buyers & sellers.
Contact SELL123.com →

Market Context

Market Context

Population: 221  ·  Density: 19.6/mi²  ·  Median household income: $74,375

Typical home value: $300,181  ·  Homeownership: 94.9%

Market Overview

Active Listings
10
⇧ 150% vs 4 last year
Pending
2
20% pending ratio
Median Price
$599,900
⇧ 37% vs $437,900 last year
Average Price
$698,611
⇧ 17.6% vs $593,967 last year
Days on Market
37
⇩ 49.3% vs 73 days last year

Price Per Square Foot

Median $/sqft
$424
⇧ 57% vs $270/sqft last year
Median Home Size
1,415 sqft
Typical listing size
12-Month $/sqft Trend

Sale-to-List Price Dynamics

At Original Price
99%
Listings with no price change
Price Reduced
1%
—
12-Month Price Reduction Trend

Based on listing price changes before sale/pending as a proxy for sale-to-list dynamics. Source: Realtor.com.

Market Trends

Inventory & Days on Market

Year over Year
  • Listings: 10 this year vs 4 last year
  • Days on market: 37 now vs 73 last year

Median & Average Pricing

Year over Year
  • Median: $599,900 (+37% YoY)
  • Average: $698,611 (+17.6% YoY)

12-Month Price Trend

Median & Average
  • Median and average listing prices over the past 12 months

12-Month Inventory Trend

Active & Pending
  • Active and pending listing counts over the past 12 months

Historical Trend Charts

Median Price
Average Price
Days on Market
Total Listings
Pending Listings
Active Listings
New Listings
Price Per Sqft
Price Reduced %

Nearby Real Estate Markets

Median Price Legend:
< $250K
$250K–$500K
$500K–$1M
$1M–$2M
> $2M
25 Nearby Zip Code Markets within 29.8 miles — 288 listings ($101,356,981 combined market value)
Zip City / State Distance Listings Market Value Median $ Average $
43438Kelleys Island, OH 434380.0 mi2$842,500$421,250$421,250
43456Put In Bay, OH 434567.1 mi8$10,965,368$869,750$1,370,671
44870Sandusky, OH 4487013.6 mi117$35,887,761$228,000$306,733
44824Castalia, OH 4482416.3 mi8$2,128,296$269,900$266,037
43464Vickery, OH 4346418.2 mi3$825,000$275,000$275,000
44814Berlin Heights, OH 4481422.9 mi11$7,108,563$438,700$646,233
43449Oak Harbor, OH 4344923.2 mi22$5,934,368$271,475$269,744
44847Monroeville, OH 4484725.8 mi3$667,350$148,675$222,450
44828Flat Rock, OH 4482826.8 mi1$66,000$66,000$66,000
44857Norwalk, OH 4485727.4 mi42$13,837,698$269,950$329,469
44053Lorain, OH 4405327.8 mi55$15,746,555$266,725$286,301
43432Graytown, OH 4343228.4 mi2$439,950$219,975$219,975
44889Wakeman, OH 4488929.8 mi14$6,907,572$375,000$493,398

Frequently Asked Questions

How many homes are for sale in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438?

As of October 2026, there are 10 active listings in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH (zip code 43438), compared to 4 the prior year.

What is the median home price in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438?

The median listing price in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438 is $599,900 as of October 2026, a 37% increase from $437,900 the prior year.

How long do homes stay on the market in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH?

Homes in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438 spend an average of 37 days on the market before going under contract, compared to 73 days the prior year.

Is it a seller's or buyer's market in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438?

Based on current inventory and days-on-market data as of October 2026, KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438 is currently a Balanced Market. Inventory has increased compared to last year, with 6 more homes available — giving buyers more choice. Homes are selling faster, averaging 37 days on market compared to 73 days last year.

How much can I save on real estate commission in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH?

With SELL123.com's maximum 3% commission, sellers in KELLEYS ISLAND, OH 43438 save an estimated $11,998 compared to a typical 5% commission on the median listing price of $599,900. Our fee structure: 1% listing + 2% selling broker — no additional buyer or seller fees. Call (240) SELL-123 or email info@SELL123.com for a free consultation.